Indy Auto Man
Closed. Opens Monday at 9:00 AM

5 Best Hard Top Convertibles for the 2024 and 2025 Seasons: Choose by Make and Price Level

Sort hard top convertibles by make and price level in the Indy Auto Man car dealerships in Indiana inventory

There are plenty of great convertibles on the US market these days. And even though old convertible models such as the Mercedes-Benz E-Class and C-Class disappeared and were replaced by one CLE-Class, outstanding used models are still available. The same is true for the Audi TT and Nissan Z Roadster.

At Indy Auto Man, Indiana car dealership, you can choose from a dozen soft and hard top convertibles, sorting the inventory online by make and price level. From ultra-cheap and cheerful to supercars and everything in between - we have new arrivals at the Indianapolis car lot each week!

Driving a car without a roof is an experience you should go through to fall in love with a convertible. This is especially vibrant when you have a musical exhaust note that filters and echoes off the surrounding landscape. Opening the windows or sunroof only allows you to enjoy a fraction of the emotions, as nothing can match the feeling of the wind enveloping you and the complete absence of a roof overhead.

The disadvantages can be just as severe as the advantages when you are in the wrong circumstances. Riding top-down often means you may be exposed to more road noise and poorer visibility than sitting in a coupe. And when it comes to dynamics and performance, convertibles are inherently compromised in weight and structural rigidity. However, we still think the pros outweigh the cons if your main goal is to just have fun!

Below, we'll take a look at some of the convertibles that might be considered the best to buy in the 2024 summer season at the Indiana car market, so read on! 

Chevrolet Corvette

corvette hard top convertible from Indianapolis dealer
  • Pros: Excellent handling and dynamics, large luggage capacity, truly magnificent interior.
  • Cons: Visibility with the roof open is not much greater than from the standard coupe roof.

Technically, any Chevrolet Corvette can drop its roof, although the most open version of the C8 is still a true convertible. Why the Corvette makes this list should be clear to everyone - it offers supercar-like performance at a fraction of the price of a supercar and does so without looking cheap or sacrificing interior quality. Choose from the regular Stingray, the tricky E-Re, or the manic Z06 - you will have a hurricane of emotions in any version.

Mazda MX-5 Miata (Roadster)

  • Pros: Light and compact, excellent engine and transmission combination. Delivers one of the most amazing driving experiences.
  • Cons: Not suitable for tall people; the infotainment system is outdated; tiny trunk.

If you don't need a 4-seat hardtop convertible, you'll be just as happy driving it as any of the more expensive offerings that follow. That's the magic of the Miata MX-5. Its diminutive dimensions, low curb weight, good 1.5L or 2.0L engines, and six-speed manual transmission make it one of the best cars of this price level you can buy today. You can raise or lower a manual roof faster than any electric one, taking only 4-5 seconds. The RF hardtop convertible is the one for you if you want an electric roof, but it hardly matters which one you get because if you're going to drive a Miata, you're guaranteed to have fun. This car is truly a masterpiece of engineering and one of the best convertibles!

Porsche 718 Boxster

  • Pros: Amazing flat-six engines and transmissions. Excellent comfort, large trunk.
  • Cons: Expensive, especially when adding options; The 4-cylinder versions can't match the sound of the flat-six, and this model is starting to become obsolete.

If you're a Miata enthusiast, then you'll definitely be tempted to purchase this Porsche if you happen to have some extra cash in your bank account. The Porsche 718 Boxster is one of the most enjoyable cars in the world, offering both powerful turbocharged 4-cylinder engines and a stunning-sounding naturally aspirated flat-six. And even though the Boxster is only a two-seater, it's one of the most practical hardtop convertibles on this list, thanks to its mid-engine layout that results in a spacious, comfortable cabin and a large boot that'll give you plenty of luggage space for the weekend.

BMW Z4

BMW Z4 hard top buy used | car lots in Indiana
  • Pros: Superb handling, luxurious interior with the latest technology, beautiful color options for both exterior and interior.
  • Cons: High price: much more expensive than its platform brother - the Toyota GR Supra.

The BMW Z4 occupies the same niche as the Boxster, but it plays its tune and is shockingly good. The performance is all there, especially if you opt for the M40i with the turbocharged inline-six, plus BMW's luxury features and technology. The only controversial decision of this car is its design on the outside; if it suits you, then the Z4 hardtop convertible will undoubtedly delight you and those around you.

Ford Mustang

auto sale Indianapolis | hard top convertible Ford Mustang
  • Pros: The muscle car looks great! Powerful engines, manual transmission available with a V8 engine, well-equipped car interior.
  • Cons: Their prices are constantly rising. An incomprehensible 4-cylinder turbo engine for such a car.

If you want to drive a full-fledged 4-passenger convertible for a fraction of the cost, then a used Ford Mustang may be a perfect option. However, they have never made its hardtop convertible variant. Why do we put it on this list? Because it's a solid reason to change your mind on soft top.  

It comes in either the fuel-efficient four-cylinder EcoBoost version or a 5.0-liter V8 in the GT. The performance/price ratio of the Mustang GT convertible is best for those who want to drive fast with the roof down and the wind in their hair. The performance you get from this beast is undoubtedly impressive. Ford's interior technology is top-notch, and the exterior design speaks louder than words. This Mustang convertible is awesome, and it's on our list of top 5 convertibles to buy in Indiana!

If you are here, then you are already in the right mood. Fill in the form below, and we will get in touch to discuss your preferences or let you know about the new hardtop convertibles of any make and price level in our Indianapolis dealerships’ inventory!

Get your trade-in value
We want to buy your car!
Instantly get your trade-in value
Check out our featured vehicles